Pia was voted off of American Idol last night after giving one of her best performances ever on Wednesday night!! This is the one big problem I have with American Idol. Not matter how great and talented the woman are over the last 5 years men have won the competition!! Everyone sent home in the Top 13 this year have been female!! Of the Top 8 left on Idol Haley and Lauren are the only gals left in the competition. I wish American Idol would do what DWTS does and have the audience vote and the judges vote go in together. See Pia's shocking elimination below!